Pope León XIV’s Critique Masks the Reality: Protecting Borders is Not Inhumanity

In a recent address at the Vatican, Pope León XIV decried what he called “increasingly inhumane” measures against immigrants, claiming some border protections are “celebrated politically.” But amidst these grand moral proclamations lies a dangerous disregard for a fundamental principle that safeguards American families and preserves national sovereignty: the right and duty of states to protect their borders.

Is Border Security Really Inhumane or a Pillar of Sovereignty?

The pope’s assertion that states must balance border security with providing refuge sounds compassionate on surface, yet it dangerously oversimplifies complex realities facing nations like the United States. America’s southern border crisis exemplifies this challenge. Rampant illegal crossings strain resources, fuel crime, and undermine the rule of law—all while lawmakers debate policies detached from on-the-ground consequences.

To question America’s sovereign authority to enforce its borders undercuts longstanding principles of national self-determination. This is not about treating individuals as “undesirables” but about ensuring orderly immigration aligned with laws reflecting American values and interests. When officials fail to uphold those laws, it is not humanity that suffers—it is national security and economic stability.

Humanity Thrives Under Lawful Order, Not Political Celebrations of Chaos

Pope León XIV’s rhetoric framing border enforcement as criminal or “deshumanizing” ignores the chaos wrought by open-border advocates who often dismiss legitimate concerns about security and economic impact. For hardworking Americans already burdened by inflation and job competition, unchecked immigration policies pose tangible threats.

True compassion does not abandon rule of law in favor of political virtue signaling. It recognizes that protecting citizens’ safety must come first—a stance championed by America First leaders who emphasize strong borders as essential to preserving liberty.

Rather than applauding political posturing that romanticizes migration without accountability, we should focus on policies that secure borders while offering genuine refuge through legal channels. This approach preserves national dignity and protects vulnerable populations from exploitation by human traffickers and cartels profiting from disorder.

The pope’s call to feed the hungry and shelter the homeless resonates deeply; however, these acts flourish best in societies where law prevails over chaos—and where governments first secure their own citizens’ well-being.